Skip to main content
P
ProPicked
AI Tools
Browse AI Tools
AI Writing ToolsAI Image GeneratorsAI Video ToolsAI Coding AssistantsAI ChatbotsAI Voice & SpeechAI Music ToolsAI Research Tools
All AI ToolsComparisons
SaaS Tools
Browse SaaS Tools
CRM SoftwareProject ManagementHR SoftwareHelp Desk & SupportTeam CommunicationDocument ManagementERP SystemsScheduling & Booking
All SaaS ToolsComparisons
E-commerce
Browse E-commerce
Online Store BuildersPayment ProcessingShipping & FulfillmentInventory ManagementMarketplace PlatformsE-commerce AnalyticsSubscription BillingReview Management
All E-commerceComparisons
Marketing Tools
Browse Marketing Tools
Email MarketingSEO ToolsSocial Media ManagementContent MarketingAdvertising PlatformsMarketing AnalyticsLanding Page BuildersMarketing Automation
All Marketing ToolsComparisons
Web Hosting
Browse Web Hosting
Shared HostingVPS HostingCloud HostingWordPress HostingDomain RegistrarsCDN ServicesDatabase GUI ToolsDNS Management
All Web HostingComparisons
Business Tools
Browse Business Tools
Accounting SoftwareLegal & ComplianceProductivity ToolsCollaboration PlatformsCybersecurity ToolsNo-Code / Low-CodeCompliance AutomationIdentity & Access Management
All Business ToolsComparisons
Best Of
โญ Reviewsโ˜‘ Features๐Ÿ’ฐ Pricing๐Ÿ†• Free Tools๐Ÿ’ฐ Budgetโฐ Free Trials๐Ÿงฎ Calculators๐ŸŽฏ By Role๐Ÿข By Industry๐Ÿ“š Buyer's Guides๐Ÿ“ˆ Trendsโš– Free vs Paid๐Ÿ›  By Use Case๐Ÿ”„ Alternatives๐Ÿ’ฐ By Price๐Ÿ“– Glossary๐Ÿ“ Blog
๐Ÿค–AI Toolsโ˜๏ธSaaS๐Ÿ›’E-commerce๐Ÿ“ขMarketing๐Ÿ–ฅ๏ธHosting๐Ÿ’ผBusiness๐Ÿ†Best OfโญReviewsโ˜‘๏ธFeatures๐Ÿ’ฐPricing๐Ÿ†“Free Tools๐Ÿ“šBuyer's Guidesโš–๏ธFree vs Paid๐Ÿ”งBy Use Case๐Ÿ”„Alternatives๐Ÿ’ฒBy Price๐ŸขBy Industry๐ŸงฎCalculators๐Ÿ“‹Decision Memo๐Ÿ“Blog
AboutContactPrivacy

Stay Ahead of the Curve

Weekly tool reviews, pricing updates, and comparison guides โ€” curated by our editorial team.

P
ProPicked

Independent software reviews and comparisons. We verify pricing, score, and compare tools so you can make confident decisions โ€” no sponsorships, no pay-to-play rankings.

1,000+ Tools Reviewed & Scored
100% Editorially Independent
Pricing Verified Monthly

Categories

  • AI Tools
  • SaaS Tools
  • E-commerce
  • Marketing Tools
  • Web Hosting
  • Business Tools

Comparisons

  • ChatGPT vs Claude
  • Shopify vs WooCommerce
  • Ahrefs vs Semrush
  • HubSpot vs Salesforce
  • Vercel vs Render
  • Zapier vs Make
  • Stripe vs PayPal

Best Of 2026

  • AI Writing Tools
  • CRM Software
  • Email Marketing
  • WordPress Hosting
  • Store Builders
  • SEO Tools
  • Project Management
  • All Best-of Lists

Popular Tools

  • ChatGPT
  • Shopify
  • HubSpot
  • Ahrefs
  • Notion
  • Vercel
  • Stripe
  • Semrush
  • Claude
  • Webflow

Discover

  • ๐Ÿ†“ Free Tools
  • ๐ŸŽฏ By Use Case
  • ๐Ÿ‘ค By Role
  • ๐Ÿข By Industry
  • ๐Ÿ”ง Solve a Problem
  • ๐Ÿ’ฐ By Price
  • ๐Ÿท๏ธ Budget Options
  • โฑ๏ธ Free Trials
  • ๐Ÿ”„ Alternatives
  • โšก Stack Fit
  • ๐Ÿ”Œ Stack Simulator
  • ๐Ÿ“‹ Compare All
  • ๐Ÿ“Š Benchmarks
  • ๐Ÿงฎ Calculators
  • ๐Ÿ“ˆ Reports
  • ๐Ÿ”— Integrations
  • ๐Ÿ”€ Migration Guides
  • ๐Ÿ“‹ Decision Memo
  • ๐ŸŒ Tool Ecosystems

Company

AboutEditorial PolicyMethodologyContactPrivacyTeamTermsBlogGlossaryBadgesChangelogUpdatesSitemap

Popular Searches

Best AI toolsFree project managementCRM pricingShopify alternativesWordPress hostingBest SEO toolsSocial media toolsHelp desk softwareTools for startupsTools for freelancersFree CRMFree email toolsAI coding toolsCheapest CRMAffordable hostingLanding page buildersNo-code platformsSolve a problem

ยฉ 2026 ProPicked. All rights reserved. All trademarks belong to their respective owners.

Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This never affects our reviews or rankings. Learn more

Screaming Frog (Winner)
โ˜…8.9/10Excellent
Try Free โ†—
  1. Home
  2. /Marketing Tools
  3. /Screaming Frog vs Clearscope
Reviewed by Sarah MitchellUpdated May 4, 2026How We Review
Editor's note: This comparison is based on verified feature data, real pricing, and editorial evaluation. Where tools are close in score, we note it โ€” a 0.2-point difference is rarely meaningful in practice.
Provider data check

We use provider pages as the source of truth.

Pricing, plan names, free plan availability, and trial details are checked against official provider pages before being used in ProPicked scores. Vendor relationships do not change rankings, scores, or recommendations.

Last verifiedMay 4, 2026
Screaming Frog
Free plan tracked
Provider
Clearscope
Free plan tracked
Provider
Prices may change after verification. Confirm checkout terms on the provider site before buying. See our methodology and affiliate disclosure.

Provider Pricing Facts

Provider pricing facts: Screaming Frog offers a free plan; Clearscope offers a free plan.

Source and Freshness Note

Source and freshness note: pricing, free-plan, and feature signals are compared from public provider data and updated comparison records. Last checked May 2026.

Screaming Frog vs Clearscope: Honest Comparison (2026)

Updated May 4, 2026Data verified May 2026
SM
Sarah Mitchell
๐Ÿ‘‘
Screaming Frog logo

Screaming Frog

โ˜…8.9/10WINNER

The industry-standard website crawler for technical SEO

Free PlanFrom $149/mo
Pricing checked May 2026Visit Screaming Frog โ†—
VS
Clearscope logo

Clearscope

โ˜…8.4/10

AI-powered content optimization for search performance

Free PlanFrom $129/mo
Pricing checked May 2026Visit Clearscope โ†—
๐Ÿ†Screaming Frog wins with 8.9/10 โ€” leading by 0.5 points
๐Ÿ“ŠBut Clearscope wins on Feature Score (4.6 vs 4.5)

We may earn a commission through links on this page ยท Editorial policy

Quick Verdict:

Screaming Frog wins with 8.9/10 vs 8.4/10. Choose Screaming Frog for more features. Choose Clearscope for ease of use.

TL;DR

Screaming Frog wins this comparison with a score of 8.9/10 vs 8.4/10. Both offer free plans. Screaming Frog stands out for most comprehensive technical SEO crawling tool available at any price, while Clearscope excels at highly accurate content optimization recommendations. However, Clearscope leads in our detailed feature analysis (4.6 vs 4.5).

Screaming Frog vs Clearscope Quick Comparison
FeatureScreaming FrogClearscope
Overall Rating8.9/108.4/10
Ease of Use7.5/108.3/10
Features9.3/108.0/10
Value for Money9.1/108.9/10
Customer Support7.6/108.6/10
Free PlanYes โœ“Yes โœ“
Starting Price$149/mo$129/mo
Feature Score4.5/104.6/10
Top StrengthMost comprehensive technical SEO crawling tool available at any priceHighly accurate content optimization recommendations
Biggest WeaknessOne-time annual fee of $259 is exceptional value for unlimited crawlingPremium pricing starting at $170/month
Best ForScreaming Frog is best for SEO professionals and technical marketers who need deep website crawling and auditing capabilities. It's the industry standard for agenciesContent teams focused on organic search performance
WinnerScreaming Frog (8.9/10)
Screaming Frog vs Clearscope: two names you'll hear constantly in the marketing tools world. But which one deserves your time (and money)? In a nutshell, Screaming Frog is all about "the industry-standard website crawler for technical SEO." Screaming Frog SEO Spider is a desktop-based website crawler used by SEO professionals to audit websites for technical SEO issues. Meanwhile, Clearscope takes a different route. Clearscope is an AI-powered content optimization platform that analyzes top-ranking content for any keyword and provides actionable recommendations to improve search performance. Users tend to highlight different strengths: Screaming Frog stands out for most comprehensive technical SEO crawling tool available at any price, while Clearscope gets noticed for highly accurate content optimization recommendations. Here's our full breakdown โ€” no fluff, just the facts you need to make a smart decision.
Screaming Frog logo

What is Screaming Frog?

The industry-standard website crawler for technical SEO

Screaming Frog SEO Spider is a desktop-based website crawler used by SEO professionals to audit websites for technical SEO issues. It crawls websites like a search engine, collecting data on URLs, page titles, meta descriptions, headers, redirects, broken links, and more. Trusted by agencies and in-house SEO teams worldwide, it remains the gold standard for technical site audits.

8.9
Overall Score
$149
From (has free plan)
Key Strengths
  • +Most comprehensive technical SEO crawling tool available at any price
  • +One-time annual fee of $259 is exceptional value for unlimited crawling
  • +Desktop-based tool means your data stays private and crawls run locally
Best For
  • โ€ขScreaming Frog is best for SEO professionals and technical marketers who need deep website crawling and auditing capabilities. It's the industry standard for agencies
  • โ€ขconsultants
  • โ€ขand in-house SEO teams performing regular technical site audits
Read Full Review โ†’
Clearscope logo

What is Clearscope?

AI-powered content optimization for search performance

Clearscope is an AI-powered content optimization platform that analyzes top-ranking content for any keyword and provides actionable recommendations to improve search performance. It grades content in real-time, suggests relevant terms and topics, and integrates with Google Docs and WordPress for seamless optimization workflows.

8.4
Overall Score
$129
From (has free plan)
Key Strengths
  • +Highly accurate content optimization recommendations
  • +Real-time content grading as you write
  • +Seamless Google Docs and WordPress integration
Best For
  • โ€ขContent teams focused on organic search performance
  • โ€ขSEO agencies optimizing client content at scale
  • โ€ขPublishers wanting data-driven content improvement
Read Full Review โ†’

Screaming Frog vs Clearscope: Key Differences

User Reviews
โœ“Screaming Frog: 3.100 reviews
Clearscope: 235 reviews
Overall Rating
โœ“Screaming Frog: 8.9/10
Clearscope: 8.4/10
Ease of Use
Screaming Frog: 7.5/10
โœ“Clearscope: 8.3/10
ScoresPros & ConsBest ForUse CasesWhen to SkipDecision GuideFeature ScoresFeaturesPricingVerdictFAQ
Screaming Frog|Clearscope

Screaming Frog vs Clearscope: Quick Verdict

Screaming Frog has a slight edge at 8.9/10 versus Clearscope's 8.4/10 โ€” close enough that Clearscope could still be the better fit depending on your priorities.

Choose Screaming Frog if:

  • Most comprehensive technical SEO crawling tool available at any price
  • One-time annual fee of $259 is exceptional value for unlimited crawling
  • Desktop-based tool means your data stays private and crawls run locally
  • You want the higher-rated option overall (8.9/10 vs 8.4/10)
  • You want to start for free before committing any money

Choose Clearscope if:

  • Highly accurate content optimization recommendations
  • Real-time content grading as you write
  • Seamless Google Docs and WordPress integration
  • You match the profile: content teams focused on organic search performance
  • Ease of use matters to you โ€” Clearscope scores 8.3/10 here

Decision Summary

Who wins in each scenario? A quick look at how Screaming Frog and Clearscope compare across different buyer needs.

๐Ÿ†Best Overall
Screaming Frog

Scores 8.9/10 vs 8.4/10

๐Ÿ’ฐBest Value
Screaming Frog

Scores 9.1/10 on value vs 8.9/10

๐Ÿš€Easiest to Adopt
Clearscope

Ease of use: 8.3/10 vs 7.5/10

๐ŸขBest for Enterprise
Screaming Frog

Features + support avg: 8.4/10 vs 8.3/10

๐ŸŒฑBest for Startups
Screaming Frog

Free plan available + 9.1/10 value

๐ŸŽฏLowest Cost Entry
Tie โ€” Screaming Frog & Clearscope

Both offer free plans

Which One Should You Choose?

Based on features, pricing, and ratings โ€” here's when each tool is the better pick.

Choose Screaming Frog If

  • โ†’You want the higher-rated overall solution (Screaming Frog: 8.9 vs Clearscope: 8.4)
  • โ†’You need the most comprehensive feature set (Screaming Frog: 9.3/10)

Choose Clearscope If

  • โ†’Budget is your priority โ€” Clearscope starts at $129/mo vs $149/mo
  • โ†’Ease of use matters most โ€” Clearscope scores 8.3/10 vs 7.5/10
  • โ†’You need enterprise-grade customer support (Clearscope: 8.6/10)
Screaming Frog: 8.9/10 ยท from $149/mo ยท free plan|Clearscope: 8.4/10 ยท from $129/mo ยท free plan

Freshness

Screaming Frog:Review updated 1 months agoโ†’Clearscope:Review updated 1 months agoโ†’
Screaming Frog logo

Choose Screaming Frog if you need...

  • โœ“Most comprehensive technical SEO crawling tool available at any price
  • โœ“One-time annual fee of $259 is exceptional value for unlimited crawling
  • โœ“Desktop-based tool means your data stays private and crawls run locally
Watch out for
  • !Most comprehensive technical SEO crawling tool available at any price
  • !One-time annual fee of $259 is exceptional value for unlimited crawling
Clearscope logo

Choose Clearscope if you need...

  • โœ“Highly accurate content optimization recommendations
  • โœ“Real-time content grading as you write
  • โœ“Seamless Google Docs and WordPress integration
  • โœ“Lower starting price ($129/mo vs $149/mo)
Watch out for
  • !Premium pricing starting at $170/month
  • !Only focused on content optimization, not full SEO

Our Take: Screaming Frog vs Clearscope

Screaming Frog edges ahead with a 8.9/10 vs 8.4/10. The gap is noticeable but not dramatic โ€” both are legitimate options depending on what you prioritize.

Where they differ: Screaming Frog's biggest strengths are most comprehensive technical SEO crawling tool available at any price and one-time annual fee of $259 is exceptional value for unlimited crawling. Clearscope, on the other hand, shines with highly accurate content optimization recommendations and real-time content grading as you write. These reflect fundamentally different product priorities.

Both offer free plans, so you can test each one with zero risk before committing. We recommend trying both for a week with real data.

Screaming Frog vs Clearscope Score Comparison

8.9
Screaming Frog
3 categories won
VS
8.4
Clearscope
2 categories won
CategoryScreaming FrogClearscope
🏆Overall Score
8.9
โ–ฒ
โ—€
8.4
💫Ease of Use
7.5
โ–ถ
โ–ฒ
8.3
⚙Features
9.3
โ–ฒ
โ—€
8.0
💰Value for Money
9.1
โ–ฒ
โ—€
8.9
💬Customer Support
7.6
โ–ถ
โ–ฒ
8.6

Why These Scores? Our Reasoning

Screaming Frog logoScreaming Frog โ€” 8.9/10
What earned points:
  • +Most comprehensive technical SEO crawling tool available at any price
  • +One-time annual fee of $259 is exceptional value for unlimited crawling
  • +Desktop-based tool means your data stays private and crawls run locally
What cost points:
  • -Most comprehensive technical SEO crawling tool available at any price
  • -One-time annual fee of $259 is exceptional value for unlimited crawling
Clearscope logoClearscope โ€” 8.4/10
What earned points:
  • +Highly accurate content optimization recommendations
  • +Real-time content grading as you write
  • +Seamless Google Docs and WordPress integration
What cost points:
  • -Premium pricing starting at $170/month
  • -Only focused on content optimization, not full SEO

Screaming Frog vs Clearscope Pros & Cons

Screaming Frog logoScreaming Frog8.9/10

+Strengths

  • โœ“Most comprehensive technical SEO crawling tool available at any price
  • โœ“One-time annual fee of $259 is exceptional value for unlimited crawling
  • โœ“Desktop-based tool means your data stays private and crawls run locally

-Weaknesses

  • โœ—Most comprehensive technical SEO crawling tool available at any price
  • โœ—One-time annual fee of $259 is exceptional value for unlimited crawling
  • โœ—Desktop-based tool means your data stays private and crawls run locally
Clearscope logoClearscope8.4/10

+Strengths

  • โœ“Highly accurate content optimization recommendations
  • โœ“Real-time content grading as you write
  • โœ“Seamless Google Docs and WordPress integration
  • โœ“Competitive analysis reveals content gaps

-Weaknesses

  • โœ—Premium pricing starting at $170/month
  • โœ—Only focused on content optimization, not full SEO
  • โœ—No free tier or trial period

Who Should Use Screaming Frog vs Clearscope?

Screaming Frog logo

Screaming Frog is ideal for

  • โ€ขScreaming Frog is best for SEO professionals and technical marketers who need deep website crawling and auditing capabilities. It's the industry standard for agencies
  • โ€ขconsultants
  • โ€ขand in-house SEO teams performing regular technical site audits
Top use cases
Site Migrations:Map old URLs to new URLs and validate redirect implementations.Large-Scale Audits:Crawl enterprise sites with millions of pages using custom extraction rules.
Clearscope logo

Clearscope is ideal for

  • โ€ขContent teams focused on organic search performance
  • โ€ขSEO agencies optimizing client content at scale
  • โ€ขPublishers wanting data-driven content improvement
Top use cases
Campaign ManagementLead GenerationPerformance AnalyticsCompetitive Intelligence

When NOT to Choose Screaming Frog or Clearscope

Knowing when a tool is the wrong fit is just as important as knowing its strengths

Screaming Frog logo

Skip Screaming Frog if...

  • โœ—Most comprehensive technical SEO crawling tool available at any price
  • โœ—One-time annual fee of $259 is exceptional value for unlimited crawling
  • โœ—Desktop-based tool means your data stays private and crawls run locally
Clearscope logo

Skip Clearscope if...

  • โœ—Premium pricing starting at $170/month
  • โœ—Only focused on content optimization, not full SEO
  • โœ—No free tier or trial period

Screaming Frog vs Clearscope Decision Framework

Choose based on what matters most to you

๐Ÿ’ฐ
Budget is your top concern$129/mo vs $149/mo
Clearscope logoClearscope
โšก
You need to get started quicklyEase of use: 8.3/10 vs 7.5/10
Clearscope logoClearscope
๐Ÿ”ง
Feature depth matters mostFeature score: 4.6/10 vs 4.5/10
Clearscope logoClearscope
๐Ÿ›Ÿ
You need reliable supportSupport: 8.6/10 vs 7.6/10
Clearscope logoClearscope
๐Ÿงช
You want to try before buyingScreaming Frog: free plan vs Clearscope: free plan
Tie
Need a shareable comparison?Generate a Decision Memo with budget analysis and team fit assessment
Generate Memo

Screaming Frog vs Clearscope Pricing

Pricing FeatureScreaming FrogClearscope
Free Planโœ“ Yesโœ“ Yes
Starting Price$149/mo$129/mo
Free TrialNot availableNot available
Number of Plans33
Value Rating9.1/108.9/10
Screaming Frog logo

Screaming Frog Plans

Free
Free
  • โœ“500 URL crawl limit
  • โœ“Basic analysis
  • โœ“Export to CSV
Paid
$259/mo
  • โœ“Unlimited crawling
  • โœ“Custom extraction
  • โœ“JavaScript rendering
Log File Analyser
$149/mo
  • โœ“Log file analysis
  • โœ“Bot identification
  • โœ“Crawl visualization
Clearscope logo

Clearscope Plans

EssentialsPOPULAR
$129/mo
  • โœ“100 content inventory pages
  • โœ“50 keyword discoveries/mo
  • โœ“20 content reports/mo
Business
$399/mo
  • โœ“300 content inventory pages
  • โœ“Dedicated account manager
  • โœ“50 keyword discoveries/mo
Enterprise
Free
  • โœ“Custom pricing
  • โœ“SSO support
  • โœ“Custom usage credits

What You Get: Plan Feature Comparison

Comparing Screaming Frog's Paid ($259/mo) vs Clearscope's Essentials ($129/mo)

FeatureScreaming FrogClearscope
Unlimited crawlingโœ“โœ—
Custom extractionโœ“โœ—
JavaScript renderingโœ“โœ—
100 content inventory pagesโœ—โœ“
50 keyword discoveries/moโœ—โœ“
20 content reports/moโœ—โœ“
๐Ÿ’ฐ
Best Value: Screaming FrogBased on starting price and value-for-money rating

Which Should You Choose?

Screaming Frog logo

Screaming Frog

Read Review โ†’Try Free โ†—
Clearscope logo

Clearscope

Read Review โ†’Try Free โ†—
Best Overall
Screaming Frog
Start Free โ†—
Best on Budget
Clearscope
Free Plan โ†—
Best for Teams
Clearscope
Book Demo โ†—

Quick Buyer's Guide

Based on our analysis, here's who each tool is best suited for

Screaming Frog logoScreaming Frog is best for:
  • โœ“Screaming Frog is best for SEO professionals and technical marketers who need deep website crawling and auditing capabilities. It's the industry standard for agencies
  • โœ“consultants
  • โœ“Users who need most comprehensive technical SEO crawling tool available at any price
Full Review โ†’Pricing โ†’Alternatives โ†’
Clearscope logoClearscope is best for:
  • โœ“Content teams focused on organic search performance
  • โœ“SEO agencies optimizing client content at scale
  • โœ“Users who need highly accurate content optimization recommendations
  • โœ“Teams with tighter budgets ($129/mo vs $149/mo)
Full Review โ†’Pricing โ†’Alternatives โ†’
Cite this page
APA

ProPicked Editorial (2026). Screaming Frog vs Clearscope (2026). ProPicked. https://propicked.com/marketing/compare/screaming-frog-vs-clearscope

BibTeX
@misc{propicked2026marketingcomparescreamingfro,
  author = {ProPicked Editorial},
  title = {Screaming Frog vs Clearscope (2026)},
  year = {2026},
  publisher = {ProPicked},
  url = {https://propicked.com/marketing/compare/screaming-frog-vs-clearscope}
}

Methodology: see our editorial policy. Provider data verified as of May 4, 2026.

๐Ÿ’ก

Screaming Frog vs Clearscope: The Bottom Line

For most teams, Screaming Frog is the safer bet โ€” but Clearscope has its own strengths.

## Our Verdict Screaming Frog has a slight edge at 8.9/10 versus Clearscope's 8.4/10 โ€” close enough that Clearscope could still be the better fit depending on your priorities. ### Choose Screaming Frog if: - Most comprehensive technical SEO crawling tool available at any price - One-time annual fee of $259 is exceptional value for unlimited crawling - Desktop-based tool means your data stays private and crawls run locally - You want the higher-rated option overall (8.9/10 vs 8.4/10) - You want to start for free before committing any money ### Choose Clearscope if: - Highly accurate content optimization recommendations - Real-time content grading as you write - Seamless Google Docs and WordPress integration - You match the profile: content teams focused on organic search performance - Ease of use matters to you โ€” Clearscope scores 8.3/10 here Clearscope at 8.4/10 is still competitive and may be the better fit depending on your specific requirements and budget.

Try Screaming Frog โ†—Try Clearscope โ†—
๐Ÿ†
Top Rated
๐Ÿ’ฐ
Pricing Guide
๐Ÿ“š
Buyer's Guide
โœ“
Free Options
๐Ÿ“ˆ
All Comparisons
๐Ÿ“Š
All Marketing Tools

Screaming Frog vs Clearscope: Related Searches

Screaming Frog vs Clearscope pricingBest Marketing Tools 2026Screaming Frog alternativesClearscope alternativesScreaming Frog pricingClearscope pricingFree seo tools toolsMarketing Tools comparison 2026Automated Client ReportingTools for Digital MarketingBest for Marketing Agencies
๐Ÿ“…Last updated: May 4, 2026
โœ…Prices verified
๐Ÿ“ŠProvider data and public review signals